"Well done bungie...but"3.5 starson by Pharts
Pros: very pretty gameplay, online options
Cons: multiplayer, framerate, repetition
Summary: The good: (online multiplayer) Tons of eye-candy, custom armor, replay, record/screen capture, fileshare, super customizable private games, and the incredible Forge.
The Bad: (Online multiplayer) The frame rate isn't very impressive. (you'll notice the difference if you play COD4 for while then go back to halo3), multiplayer gets a bit mundane if you just play matchmaking (they need more game variants, or atleast some good classics like SWAT), They've fixed melee (was terrible enough to make me stop playing until they fixed it), there's been some terrible lag instances that you wouldn't experience in any other game, and the mauler weapon makes lousy players think they have skills.